I’m not sure what exactly your troubles are currently.
@GTJohn @MarcSaunier @ArtEyes I’ve made a demo file containing a mountain with lowlands, a road and dunes that partially cover the road. I didn’t make it look too pretty, the main purpose was to have the colours of the base, the road and the sand clearly distinct from each other to see how the masking works.
You can tweak anything in the nodes (including rearranging the road spline etc) and the masks will stay clean and where they should be, including sand always keeping its colour over the road and the road keeping its colour over the terrain.
Help 14 (Texturing roads with covering sand).terrain (54.5 KB)
If you have any questions, feel free to ping me for help.
the Sand output of the dune node is broken, or the Dune node needs an additional output (If I’m misunderstanding what the Sand output is meant to be)
Not broken, but it’s misleading.
“Sand” output is displayed as the actual amount of sand, so it’s in the range of 0-1 relative to your project limits (0 = min height, 1 = max height), same as water masks’ “Depth” outputs. It’s meant to indicate the amount of sand, not to be a hard mask. There is currently no hard mask for sand. To make one, use “Sand” with Threshold (0.0001 works the best). It’s in the file, you can find it to see how it works. “Sand” reflecting the amount of sand has the logic behind it so that you can chain Dunes nodes, plugging Sand into Sand to manipulate it further (say, the first Dunes node has a big scale and certain dune formation, the second has much lower scale and another formation or even wind direction).
It’s misleading because with other masks Snow and Water provide you hard masks, not here. I’ve told the devs about it, but I’m only a single voice, if you also find it confusing, you can always file feedback tickets in the app, those help, Quadspinner read everything, so the more people say that it’s a UX problem, the more likely it is to get reviewed.
P. S. @TyXanders Kindly merge this topic with this topic, they are essentially one thread scattered in two places at this point.
P. P. S. Some project screenshots for visualisation:





